“Oh, what a tangled web we weave. When first we practise to deceive!” wrote Walter Scott. Ms. Nathan exposes a very tangled web indeed. ‘Sybil Exposed’ is a meticulously researched and well written book; a stern warning against naiveté and gullibility. How easy it is to believe even the wildest of tales when one WANTS to believe it!
The book’s +/- 600 references back up the author’s assertion of duplicity of everyone involved in the book’s creation. One issue not definitively clear is whether the ‘Sybil’ fraud was premeditated or calculated or whether Shirley, Connie, Flora, et. al. just got caught up in the thing. Maybe, like Topsy, the deception just ‘grow’d’. A first lie generates a second and together they spawn an infestation. “Things come apart so easily when they have been held together with lies.” said Dorothy Allison. If true, how did SO many accept the veracity of ‘Sybil’ SO completely for SO long? If the consequences were not so serious the whole affair would be laughable.
This book is a must for anyone who has ever read "Sybil."
This is a must read if you believe Sybil as fact. Nathan's research shows us how it all came about. Fascinating book. I recommend it to anyone interested in psychology.
I always was suspicious of the story of "Sybil", and this book exposes the fraud completely. Basically, the psychiatrist, the patient and the author of the book were liars. Connie Wilbur (the psychiatrist) seemed to be a particularly sadistic women to boot. It's scary what is done in the name of that pseudo-science. The doctors have absolute control over their patients and don't have any idea what they are doing. Great book!
The last paragraph of the book sums it up neatly: "Psychotheray can do enormous good when it is cautious about delving into the mind, skeptical of anyone offering definitve answers, wary of the overly confident, critical about the political and social milieu in which it operates, and accepting of the enormity of what we do not know. When healers and the public ignore these tenets, however, what emerges--on the couch and in the culture--can be as powerful yet pernicious as Sybil exposed."
This book exposes the falsehoods behind the famous book "Sybil" and the subsequent movie with Sally Fields. The diagnosis of multiple personality disorder is now considered unreliable but at one point in its popularity, tens of thousands of people (mainly women) were given this diagnosis. The psychiatrist involved in the "Sybil" case was instrumental in the popularization of multiple personality disorder.
The author of this new book proves that the patient was prompted by her psychiatrist, by hypnosis, and the use of drugs to come up with the bizarre abuse fantasies that she presented to her psychiatrist to keep her psychiatrist interested. The psychiatrist was grossly unethical and encouraged an attachment from the patient that led to an incredible dependency lasting the rest of their lives, off and on. The psychiatrist visited the patient at home, loaned her money, went on vacations with her, sold her artwork, etc. Not to mention making money off the very frequent sessions over the many years of therapy.
The patient tries at one point to come clean and admits in a letter that she lied about the multiple personalities because that was the psychiatrist's special interest but the psychiatrist would have none of it; she considered the confession letter to be evidence of resistance and denial.
There's also information about how the author of the book changed things to make the book more sensationalistic so it would sell better. It's all a very sad story about the greed for money and fame.
It might be too thin a story to hang an entire book on, but Debbie Nathan's graceful handling of the material makes it an enjoyable, if occasionally monotonous, read.
There are no ages for this title yet.
There are no summaries for this title yet.
There are no notices for this title yet.
There are no quotes for this title yet.